After a life insurance claim has already been denied, many beneficiaries are surprised to receive a new request from the insurance company. The letter often sounds cooperative. It may say the insurer wants to conduct an interview, take a recorded statement, or clarify a few issues before reconsidering the claim.
In reality, a post denial interview request is rarely a neutral step. It is usually a strategic move by the insurer to strengthen its denial, limit exposure, or gather statements that can be used against the beneficiary later.
Understanding why insurers ask for interviews after denial, and how to respond, can make the difference between recovering benefits and permanently damaging the claim.
Why Insurers Request Interviews After a Denial
Once a claim has been denied, the insurance company already believes it has grounds to avoid payment. An interview at this stage is not about helping the beneficiary. It is about protecting the insurer.
Common reasons insurers demand interviews after denial include:
• Locking the beneficiary into statements that support the denial
• Filling gaps in underwriting or medical records
• Developing new defenses not clearly stated in the denial letter
• Creating inconsistencies that can be cited in litigation
• Testing how prepared or legally represented the beneficiary is
In many cases, the insurer already has the medical records, application, and claim file. The interview is designed to generate new evidence, not to clarify existing facts.
The Danger of Recorded Statements After Denial
Insurers often request recorded or transcribed interviews. These statements are rarely informal, even when described that way.
Once recorded, every answer becomes evidence. Minor wording choices can later be framed as misrepresentations, admissions, or inconsistencies.
Examples of how statements are used against beneficiaries include:
• Mischaracterizing casual remarks as proof of nondisclosure
• Comparing interview answers to decades old medical records
• Arguing that uncertainty equals dishonesty
• Claiming memory gaps show intent to deceive
Beneficiaries are frequently questioned about medical history, lifestyle, finances, and conversations with the insured. These topics are fertile ground for insurer defenses.
Are You Required to Submit to an Interview After Denial
The answer depends on the policy and the timing.
Many policies require cooperation during the claims investigation. However, once a formal denial has been issued, the insurer’s right to demand further cooperation is often far more limited.
In some cases:
• The policy does not require post denial interviews
• The interview request is voluntary, not mandatory
• The insurer is attempting to reopen investigation without formally reopening the claim
Agreeing to an interview without understanding your rights can weaken your position, especially if litigation is anticipated.
The Interview Is Not a Reconsideration Guarantee
One of the most dangerous assumptions beneficiaries make is believing that agreeing to an interview increases the chances of approval.
In practice, post denial interviews often result in:
• A second denial that cites new reasons
• A revised denial letter that strengthens insurer defenses
• Additional delay without any real reconsideration
The insurer controls the interview, the questions, the transcript, and how answers are interpreted. The beneficiary has none of that control.
How Life Insurance Lawyers Handle Post Denial Interview Requests
Experienced life insurance attorneys approach interview demands strategically, not emotionally.
Common legal responses include:
• Declining the interview entirely
• Requiring all questions to be submitted in writing
• Limiting the scope of questioning
• Conducting the interview through counsel
• Using sworn affidavits instead of recorded statements
In many cases, refusing the interview does not harm the claim and may prevent the insurer from creating new defenses.
When an Interview May Make Sense
There are limited situations where a controlled interview can help, such as:
• Correcting clear factual errors already in the denial
• Addressing mistaken identity or record mix ups
• Clarifying employment or beneficiary designation issues
Even then, the interview should never occur without legal guidance and strict boundaries.
What to Do If You Receive an Interview Request After Denial
If an insurer demands an interview after denying your life insurance claim, take these steps immediately:
• Do not agree verbally or in writing
• Do not provide recorded statements
• Request a copy of the policy and denial letter
• Preserve all correspondence
• Speak with a life insurance attorney before responding
What feels like cooperation can quickly become evidence used to justify nonpayment.
Conclusion
A post denial interview request is rarely about fairness or reconsideration. It is usually about strengthening the insurer’s position and limiting liability.
Once a claim is denied, the rules change. Every interaction matters, and every statement can affect the outcome of an appeal or lawsuit.
Beneficiaries should treat these requests as legal events, not routine paperwork.
If you want, next I can provide a short title, meta title, and meta description that match your current blog series style, or tailor this draft to ERISA versus individual policy contexts.