New Jersey Life Insurance Lawyer

Christian Lassen, Esq. | Licensed in New Jersey (NJ 006662000) | Quoted in The Wall Street Journal | 25 Years Experience

Life Insurance Lawyers Serving All 21 New Jersey Counties

A life insurance denial in New Jersey is not the end of the claim, even when the insurer insists its decision is final. New Jersey law places real limits on how insurers investigate claims, interpret policy language, and attempt to terminate coverage after a death. Many denials violate those limits.

Beneficiaries are often denied benefits before they have even seen the full policy or understand the insurer’s reasoning. Others face indefinite delays designed to pressure families into giving up. These tactics are common, but they are not always lawful.

The Lassen Law Firm focuses exclusively on denied life insurance claims. We represent beneficiaries across all 21 New Jersey counties in disputes involving alleged misrepresentation, lapse and nonpayment claims, beneficiary conflicts, ERISA governed group life insurance, accidental death denials, and interpleader actions. We do not handle personal injury cases or unrelated insurance matters. Life insurance litigation is all we do.

Our New Jersey clients come from throughout the state, including Essex County, Bergen County, Middlesex County, Ocean County, Camden County, Morris County, Union County, and surrounding areas.

Life Insurance Claim Denials in New Jersey

Life insurance companies operating in New Jersey are required to investigate claims promptly, communicate honestly, and act in good faith. In practice, many rely on technical defenses, aggressive post claim investigations, and procedural pressure to avoid paying valid benefits.

Denials frequently arrive before families have access to the full claim file. In other cases, insurers delay payment while repeatedly requesting documents that have little relevance to the policy requirements. These delays often serve no purpose other than wearing beneficiaries down.

Many New Jersey life insurance denials can be successfully challenged once the policy language, claim handling, and insurer conduct are carefully examined.

Where New Jersey Life Insurance Disputes Are Decided

Venue plays a critical role in life insurance litigation, and insurers often select forums strategically.

Most individual policy disputes are litigated in the New Jersey Superior Court, Law Division, where breach of contract and insurer misconduct claims are resolved.

Beneficiary disputes and interpleader actions are commonly handled in the Chancery Division, particularly when an insurer deposits the policy proceeds with the court and asks a judge to determine entitlement.

Group life insurance claims governed by ERISA, along with many interpleader actions, are frequently filed in the United States District Court for the District of New Jersey.

Responding correctly to the chosen forum matters. Missed deadlines or improper filings can permanently jeopardize an otherwise valid claim.

Why Life Insurance Denials in New Jersey Follow Predictable Patterns

New Jersey life insurance denials often follow recurring patterns tied to how insurers operate within the state. Because New Jersey has a dense regulatory environment and a high concentration of insurance carriers, denials frequently rely on procedural defenses rather than clear policy exclusions.

Based on denied claims we routinely review for New Jersey beneficiaries, insurers most often rely on the following strategies.

Post claim application reviews. Insurers frequently reexamine the original application after a death and attempt to rescind coverage based on medical or lifestyle information that had no connection to the cause of death. These denials often involve routine conditions or minor inconsistencies that would not have affected underwriting.

Lapse based denials. Insurers often claim policies lapsed for nonpayment even when required notices were not properly delivered or were sent to outdated addresses. Grace period requirements are frequently ignored.

Accidental death reclassification. Accidental deaths are commonly recharacterized as medical or substance related events, even when policy language does not clearly support an exclusion. Under New Jersey law, ambiguities are typically resolved against the insurer.

Beneficiary disputes involving late changes. Last minute beneficiary designations, caregiver involvement, blended families, and estate planning gaps often trigger disputes. Insurers frequently freeze payment or file interpleader actions instead of evaluating the validity of the designation.

ERISA group life insurance errors. Employer mistakes involving enrollment, evidence of insurability, and payroll deductions are a recurring cause of denied group life insurance claims in New Jersey.

Strategic delays. Rather than issuing a denial, insurers may extend investigations indefinitely by requesting repeated documentation. Unreasonable delays can violate New Jersey claims handling standards.

Contestability Period Rules Under New Jersey Law

Most New Jersey life insurance policies include a two year contestability period. During this time, insurers may investigate whether the insured made material misstatements when applying for coverage.

Not every error justifies rescission. Under New Jersey law, only material misstatements that would have influenced the insurer’s decision to issue or price the policy may support denial. Minor inaccuracies or information unrelated to the cause of death generally do not.

Once the contestability period expires, an insurer’s ability to deny coverage based on application issues becomes sharply limited unless intentional fraud can be proven.

Federal and Employer Provided Life Insurance Claims in New Jersey

We represent New Jersey beneficiaries in denied claims involving Servicemembers’ Group Life Insurance, Veterans’ Group Life Insurance, and Federal Employees’ Group Life Insurance.

Many employer provided life insurance policies are governed by ERISA. These cases require strict administrative appeals and are decided solely on the written claim record. Evidence not submitted during the appeal is often excluded later.

Errors at the appeal stage can permanently bar recovery, which is why early involvement is critical.

Behind the Scenes of a New Jersey Life Insurance Denial

Most beneficiaries never see how life insurance claims are evaluated internally.

In New Jersey claims, insurers often assign multiple nonmedical reviewers to scrutinize applications and medical records after a death. Internal notes frequently focus on identifying inconsistencies rather than determining whether the policy should pay.

Large policies and older policies are commonly escalated internally for rescission review, particularly when the insured lived in New Jersey for many years or the policy was issued long before the death.

In beneficiary disputes, insurers often prefer to file interpleader actions instead of making a coverage decision. This shifts the burden and expense to the beneficiaries while allowing the insurer to exit the dispute.

Delays are sometimes intentional. Claims may remain open without a formal denial while insurers wait for beneficiaries to miss deadlines or abandon the claim.

Understanding these internal practices allows denied claims to be challenged more effectively.

What to Do After a Life Insurance Claim Is Denied in New Jersey

If your life insurance claim has been denied or delayed, timing matters.

Request a complete copy of the policy, application, and claim file. Preserve all insurer communications. Avoid submitting new statements or authorizations without guidance. Act quickly to protect appeal and filing deadlines.

Many New Jersey beneficiaries lose valid claims simply because they did not understand the process or the insurer’s tactics.

New Jersey Life Insurance Denial FAQs

Does New Jersey law remove an ex spouse as a beneficiary after divorce?
In most cases, yes. New Jersey law generally revokes an ex spouse’s beneficiary designation after divorce unless the designation was reaffirmed or a court order requires otherwise.

Can a life insurance company deny a claim for a medical issue unrelated to death?
No. Only material misstatements that affected underwriting can justify rescission.

What happens if two people claim the same life insurance policy?
The insurer may file an interpleader action and deposit the proceeds with the court. Each claimant must then prove entitlement.

Can an insurer delay payment without issuing a denial?
Delays are common but not always lawful. Prolonged or unjustified delays may violate New Jersey claims handling obligations.

Can a will override a life insurance beneficiary in New Jersey?
No. Life insurance proceeds pass by beneficiary designation, not by a will.

Is New Jersey a community property state?
No.

Can life insurance proceeds be taken by creditors?
Generally no, provided there is a valid named beneficiary.

Can caregiver beneficiary designations be challenged?
Yes. Caregiver designations made shortly before death frequently raise undue influence concerns and are often litigated in New Jersey courts.

Is it too late to challenge an older denial?
Not necessarily. Some denials remain challengeable depending on the policy, facts, and applicable deadlines.

How Our New Jersey Life Insurance Attorneys Handle Denied Claims

When we represent New Jersey beneficiaries, we conduct a full policy and claim review, identify contractual and statutory violations, challenge improper rescissions and exclusions, manage insurer communications and appeals, and litigate in New Jersey state or federal court when necessary.

There is no fee unless we recover benefits.

Free Case Evaluation Contact Us!

Written & Reviewed by Christian Lassen, Esq., Nationally recognized life insurance lawyer: 25 years experience.  Quoted in The Wall Street Journal ( May 17, 2025).

Last reviewed: Jan 3, 2026 | Contact 800-330-2274

New Jersey Required Disclaimer: “No aspect of this advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court of New Jersey.”

More New Jersey Cities We Serve
Elizabeth
Edison
Woodbridge
Toms River
Hamilton Township
Trenton
Clifton
Cherry Hill
Brick
Camden
Bayonne
East Orange